I have eclectic reading tastes. I read just about any genre except horror. I try to judge a book based on its own merits rather than its category. But I have to admit that the traditional “Romance” category triggers judgment in me.
I’m not saying I never read books in that category. I have read historical romances and paranormal romances and other types of romances. In my opinion, romance can make a story sizzle. But a lot of romance books are shells that have cookie-cutter characters and predictable plots that exist mainly for the sex scenes. I find such books tiring.
Granted, sex can be pretty stimulating, but when I read, I want a story that grabs me and characters who seem real and a believable plot. I don’t feel turned off if there is sex in the book, but it needs to be just one part of the story and not be the sole reason for the book.
Apparently, there is a BIG market for women who read these books. I guess their sex lives are pretty boring, and romance novels are like porn for women. Soft porn, but still pandering solely to sexual appetites. And while I don’t judge people for reading such books, I don’t really want readers to think my book falls into that category.
So when I wrote my “Autumn In The Desert” series, I was loath to put it in a Romance category, yet there isn’t another category that fits. There is an element of romance for sure in my stories. And sex happens, because it’s a part of life. But as an author, I’m not into writing steamy sex scenes. It just isn’t my thing. My stories are about real people and their entire life situations, not just their sex lives.
I wish there were a Boomer Fiction category or anything that wouldn’t misrepresent my stories. “Contemporary Romance” is about the best I can do. That and “Women’s Fiction,” which to me sounds like a literary equivalent of the junk drawer most of us have in our kitchen. I just cross my fingers and hope.
Do you read romance novels? Would you be turned off from reading my book because it’s in that category? Or would you buy it and then be disappointed that it isn’t filled with steamy sex scenes? And what the heck do you think constitutes “Women’s Fiction?” Please comment below. I’m interested in your point of view.